StarlinkDuffy remarks · reportedDUFFY SAYS FAA CHOSE A GROUND NETWORK OVER STARLINK

Starlink vs FAA Ground Network: Duffy Responds, Musk Facepalms

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says the FAA chose a ground-based network over Starlink after testing an earlier version. Elon Musk replied with a single facepalm emoji.

Illustration of a satellite dish beaming to orbit above a network of ground cables leading to a control tower
Sky or ground: the FAA's network choice is back in the spotlight. Illustration: ENNIllustration
AT A GLANCE
Duffy remarks · reported

Duffy's public remarks and Musk's emoji reply show where each side stands, but neither explains what the FAA's Starlink lab tests actually found.

What changed
Sean Duffy publicly answered Musk's free-Starlink claim
Duffy's reason
FAA tested an earlier Starlink version and preferred a ground-based network
Musk's reply
A single facepalm emoji
Ground stop
November 13; about 12,462 flights canceled by operators, per the FAA
Duffy's ask
$50 billion from Congress to modernize air traffic control
STORY THREAD Starlink and the FAA2 updates so far

The Starlink and FAA story has a new chapter. When ENN last covered it, Elon Musk had said on X that the FAA declined free Starlinks before last week’s ground stop, and the Transportation Department had not answered publicly. Now Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has answered. He says the agency chose a network based on the ground after running into problems with an earlier version of Starlink1. Musk’s reply was a single emoji: a facepalm1.

What happened

Duffy addressed Musk’s claim at a press conference, according to Teslarati1. 24/7 Wall St. places the remarks on Tuesday, November 17, and reports that Duffy praised Starlink while still turning it down for the FAA network2.

The exchange started Monday, when Musk wrote on X that free Starlinks had been offered and declined1. That post came three days after the FAA grounded departures nationwide on November 131. Musk did not let it rest there. On Tuesday night he reshared his February 2025 X post about the aging air traffic technology, adding “I wrote this 18 months ago”3.

A Starlink satellite internet terminal
A Starlink terminal. The FAA has used Starlink at some sites in Alaska.Illustration

What Duffy and Musk said

Here is Musk’s original post from Monday, November 16:

Free Starlinks for FAA were offered to Sec Duffy, but he said they were not needed. As it turns out, they were.

That wording appears in Teslarati’s report and in 24/7 Wall St.’s coverage12.

Duffy’s answer, according to a transcript published by ZeroHedge and quoted by Teslarati, began with praise1:

I’ve worked well with Elon, and he, Starlink was a great solution for some of our assets in Alaska, but we sent Starlink, in one of its prior iterations, to our tech lab, and, there was some issues that we had to navigate, and we thought that the best method is to have a network that’s based on the ground.

He went on1:

Now, I think what he’s doing with Starlink and the speed is remarkable, but, our airspace is very big. We have assets everywhere. And so, again, we used him for different parts of the airspace.

Two things stand out. Duffy did not dispute that the offer was made, and he did not say what problems the FAA found during testing1. 24/7 Wall St. puts it as Duffy not directly addressing a free offer2. So Musk’s account stands unchallenged on the central point, and the “issues” behind the FAA’s choice remain unexplained. Musk’s facepalm made his view of the answer clear2.

The ground stop behind the argument

The outage that sparked this was large. The FAA says the problem began at about 3:30 p.m. ET and traffic resumed by 8:15 p.m. the same day2. Instability hit 17 of its 22 Air Route Traffic Control Centers, and approximately 3,500 aircraft already in the air landed safely2. Business Insider calls it the largest shutdown since September 11, 2001, with no airplanes allowed to take off for over four hours3.

The FAA counts approximately 12,462 flights canceled by operators, including 9,082 by major airlines, though it notes not all were directly caused by the ground stop2. FlightAware put cancellations from Friday to Sunday at around 18,000 flights, according to FedScoop as cited by 24/7 Wall St.2, and Business Insider reports nearly 20,000 flights canceled3.

In the FAA’s telling, legacy equipment became unstable as data flooded its telecommunications network at 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds1. The agency traced the flood to a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris had been installing a new router1. The FAA disabled the same function on more than 60 other Juniper routers, paused installs, and reports no indication of a cyberattack2. Hewlett Packard Enterprise, which owns Juniper, said the device “functioned as it was configured to by the installer”2. The investigation is still underway2.

An air traffic control tower at a US airport
The November 13 ground stop halted departures nationwide.Photo: Wikimedia Commons contributor, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

How this fits the longer Starlink and FAA story

Musk has pressed this issue for a long time. In February 2025, while he was leading the Department of Government Efficiency, he wrote that “the Verizon system is not working and so is putting air travelers at serious risk,” then corrected himself days later to blame L3Harris1. His correction read: “the ancient system that is rapidly declining in capability was made L3Harris. The new system that is not yet operational is from Verizon”4. He also wrote then that the terminals were “being sent at NO COST to the taxpayer on an emergency basis to restore air traffic control connectivity”4.

SpaceX said at the time that it was supplying Starlink kits to the FAA at no cost and had no intent to take over any existing contract1. The FAA disclosed then that it was testing one Starlink terminal at its Atlantic City, New Jersey, facility and two at “non-safety critical sites” in Alaska, a state it said had long had issues with reliable weather information for aviation5. By March 2025 the FAA said it was testing Starlink in Alaska, Oklahoma City and Atlantic City, and said modernizing air traffic control “will require multiple companies and multiple technologies”3.

The FAA’s position on satellite links predates this week. In a July 2025 letter to lawmakers, FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said the agency “would not use Starlink (or any satellite service) as the sole communications technology” for safety-critical air traffic services1. Verizon’s FAA Enterprise Network Services contract, awarded in 2023, is valued at up to $2.4 billion over 15 years1.

Duffy’s “Alaska” line matches that record. Starlink earned his public praise for that work, and his comment about the speed of Musk’s Starlink progress is a notable compliment from the official who made the call1.

Independent coverage and the open questions

Not everyone agrees Starlink alone would have changed last Friday. Business Insider writes that it is unclear how Starlink terminals could have prevented the data flood, and notes that useful connections at remote sites are different from replacing the whole network linking air traffic facilities3. 24/7 Wall St. reports that no official has said satellite links would have kept planes flying2. The FAA did not immediately respond to Business Insider’s request for comment on Musk’s remarks3.

Musk’s core point, though, has company. Duffy himself is frustrated with the current setup. “I want to get away from L3Harris and get to a new one, but they own the network,” he said. “I can’t cancel the network that they own”1. He has said the country has “old switches, old routers”3, and he argues against “a patchwork, a fix to a system that’s critical for every single family”1. Both men agree the old system needs to go. They differ on what replaces it.

What to watch next

  • The money. Duffy has asked Congress for $50 billion to modernize air traffic control1. Jalopnik reports he has already received $12.5 billion for the overhaul, according to 24/7 Wall St.2
  • The investigation. FedScoop reports FAA staff and FBI agents are testing the router at an L3Harris lab in Florida2. A final cause will shape what the fix looks like.
  • The lab results. Duffy has not said what issues the earlier Starlink version showed in testing1. Details would show whether the current Starlink addresses them.
  • Thanksgiving travel. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, and heavy airport traffic is expected around it2.

For now, the record is simple. Musk says free Starlinks were offered and declined. Duffy did not dispute that, praised Starlink’s speed and its Alaska role, and said the FAA preferred a ground network. Musk’s facepalm says the rest1.

Questions readers ask

What did Sean Duffy say about Starlink?

He said Starlink was a great solution for some FAA assets in Alaska, but an earlier version tested at the FAA tech lab had issues, and the agency thought a ground-based network was the best method.

Did Duffy deny that free Starlinks were offered?

No. Teslarati reports he did not dispute that the offer was made, and 24/7 Wall St. says he did not directly address it.

How did Elon Musk respond?

With a single facepalm emoji.

What caused the November 13 ground stop?

The FAA says legacy equipment became unstable when data flooded its telecom network. Investigators are looking at sites in Amarillo, Texas, and El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris had been installing a new router. The investigation is still underway.

Sources

Each story is checked against the original material and independent reporting. Numbers in the text point here.

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5