Elon Musk has delivered a short, pointed verdict on the country where he grew up. Replying on X to a post from Semafor that tagged ABC News correspondent Jon Karl, Musk wrote on November 17: “South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians.”1 The reply landed under a clip of South African President Cyril Ramaphosa talking about Musk, and it showed about 573,000 views when Semafor’s thread was captured.2
@semafor @jonkarl South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians
— @elonmusk Nov 17, 2026
The post is one sentence. ENN reports it exactly as written and does not add meaning Musk did not state. What follows is the context: what Semafor posted, what Ramaphosa said about Musk and Starlink, and where this sits in Musk’s long-running commentary on South Africa.
What Musk posted
Musk’s words were addressed to two accounts, @semafor and @jonkarl, and read in full: “South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians.”1 The same reply appears in the conversation under Semafor’s post, directly beneath the outlet’s link to the full interview video.2
The wording will be familiar to longtime followers. In February 2023, Musk wrote that “For a *very* long time, US media was racist against non-white people, now they’re racist against whites & Asians,” adding that the “Same thing happened with elite colleges & high schools in America.”3 His new post applies a similar framing, this time to South Africa.
What the Semafor post showed
Semafor’s post, published at 8:10 PM on November 16, featured Ramaphosa speaking with Karl. It had about 831,500 views when captured.2 The quote Semafor chose to highlight was personal and, in its opening line, complimentary:
“I have met Elon Musk in the past, and I’ve been awed by his brilliance. But I’d also like to chat to him about remembering his country,” South African President Cyril Ramaphosa tells @jonkarl. “What you’ve become today is by dint of your own origins ... It is because of the knowledge. And the education that was made available to him.”
Semafor then pointed readers to the full conversation from its Silicon Valley & The World event.2 An Associated Press photo shows Ramaphosa and Karl on stage at that summit in Menlo Park, California, on Monday, November 16, 2026, and identifies Karl as ABC News’ chief Washington correspondent.4

What Ramaphosa told Semafor about Starlink
Semafor’s written report on the interview gives the larger subject. Ramaphosa told the outlet that Musk’s “difficulty in understanding” a key South African policy is the main issue preventing Starlink from launching in Africa’s biggest economy.5
That policy is Black Economic Empowerment, or BEE. Semafor describes it as introduced nearly 30 years ago to redress apartheid-era inequality, and reports that under it at least 30% of the South African operation of any company must be sold to Black locals.5 Musk, who was raised in South Africa, has called the policy “openly racist” and cited it as the reason Starlink does not operate in the country, according to Semafor.5
Ramaphosa defended the rule as normal practice. “All countries have policies in terms of how they admit companies to operate,” he told Karl. “You’ve got to subscribe to the policies of the country.”5 He also said Musk “doesn’t fully understand the extent” of the impact apartheid policies had on Black South Africans, and that Musk should be “loyal” to the country where he spent his early years.5

The positions are clear on both sides. Ramaphosa frames BEE as the price of entry that any company must accept. Musk, by Semafor’s account, has named the policy itself as the obstacle and called it “openly racist.”5 His November 17 reply does not mention Starlink or BEE by name; it is a broader statement about the country.1
Musk’s longer record on South Africa
This is far from the first time Musk has spoken up about South Africa. In March 2025, the Associated Press reported that Musk, whom it described as having regularly accused South Africa’s Black-led government of being anti-white, posted about a rally where leaders of the Economic Freedom Fighters sang a song with the lyrics “Kill the Boer, the farmer.”6 “Very few people know that there is a major political party in South Africa that is actively promoting white genocide,” Musk wrote at the time, linking to video of the rally.6
The AP noted that the EFF is the fourth biggest party in Parliament, that it won 9.5% of the vote in the previous national election, and that the song has a long legal history: it was ruled hate speech more than a decade earlier, before a 2022 ruling found it was protected speech because there was no proof it incited violence.6 The AP also reported that the song’s modern-day use has been criticized by some in South Africa, including other political parties.6
The wider US and South Africa backdrop
Semafor places the latest exchange inside a strained relationship between Washington and Pretoria. It reports that Musk’s influence is widely seen to have played a role in that relationship, and that South Africa has refused US demands for reforms of BEE.5
In the same interview, Ramaphosa described his Oval Office meeting with President Donald Trump, in which Trump accused him of presiding over a white genocide, as an “ambush,” and said Trump was “seriously misinformed.”5 Ramaphosa said the two had not spoken since that meeting.5 Semafor describes the white genocide allegation as widely discredited.5
Ramaphosa’s visit was also about technology. He said he was in California for meetings with tech executives, including talks with OpenAI, Anthropic, Microsoft and Google, and that South Africa welcomes data centers.5
Pushback and context
Musk’s commentary on race has drawn criticism before, and fairness to readers means noting it. When he posted about US media and schools in 2023, CNBC reported that he made the claims without presenting evidence and quoted civil rights attorney Brian Levin questioning whether Musk was well placed to weigh in.3
On South Africa specifically, Ramaphosa said in March 2025 that the claim that white people are being persecuted in his country is a “completely false narrative.”6 The AP reported that he did not mention names, and that his statement was pushing back against allegations made by Trump, Musk and some white minority groups in South Africa.6 The AP also reported that experts say there is no evidence of widespread targeting of whites in farm attacks, while a group representing Afrikaners says police have sometimes undercounted farm homicides.6
Musk’s stated position on the Starlink question is consistent: by Semafor’s account he sees BEE as “openly racist,” and that is the reason he has given for Starlink’s absence.5 Ramaphosa’s position is that Musk should accept the rules every company faces.5 Both men have now said so in public within a day of each other.12
What to watch next
Ramaphosa said publicly that he would like to chat with Musk.2 Whether that conversation happens is the first thing to watch. The second is Starlink: as long as BEE’s ownership requirement stands and Musk views it as he does, Semafor’s reporting suggests the service’s entry into South Africa remains stuck on that policy question.5
And given how often Musk returns to the subject of the country he grew up in, more posts are likely. ENN will follow this thread as it develops.



