ElonElon's post · 11 NovMUSK: MASA PICKED WEWORK OVER $12B FOR 1/4 OF TESLA

Tesla's $12B Road Not Taken: Musk Says Masa Chose WeWork Instead

Elon Musk says SoftBank's Masayoshi Son could have put $12 billion into Tesla for a quarter of the company to help take it private, but invested in WeWork instead.

Illustration of two diverging roads, one toward a glowing electric car and one toward a dim office tower
Two paths for $12 billion, as Musk tells it. Illustration: ENN.Illustration
AT A GLANCE
Elon's post · 11 Nov

Musk's post shows what he says happened; it does not prove the details of any offer, and SoftBank's account is not in the sources.

What Musk said
Masa invested in WeWork instead of putting $12B into Tesla for a 1/4 of the company
Purpose, per Musk
To help him take Tesla private
Musk's verdict
"That was dumb."
2018 take-private plan
$420 per share, a $72 billion deal per Reuters; dropped in August 2018
SoftBank in WeWork
About $11 billion invested by SoftBank and its Vision Fund, per Wccftech (Oct 2019)
STORY THREAD Musk on Masayoshi Son and SoftBankFirst report in this thread. Updates will appear here.

Elon Musk has offered a memorable look back at one of the biggest what-ifs in Tesla’s history. In a reply on X on 11 November, he said SoftBank’s Masayoshi Son, whom he calls Masa, chose to put $12 billion into WeWork rather than into Tesla for a quarter of the company, money Musk says would have helped him take Tesla private.1 His verdict was short and direct: “That was dumb.”1

What Musk said

The post was a reply to @KatieMiller. Here it is in full:1

I remember that time when Masa, instead of putting $12B into Tesla for a 1/4 of the company to help me take Tesla private, instead invested the money in WeWork. That was dumb.

The post sets out three specifics: the amount ($12 billion), the share of Tesla it would have bought (a quarter), and the purpose (helping Musk take Tesla private).1 It does not say when the episode happened, and it does not describe how far any conversation went. ENN reports it as Musk’s own recollection, in his own words.

It is an unusually candid glimpse into the money side of Tesla’s history, and it comes from the person at the center of it. For fans who followed Tesla through its toughest stretch, the post is a reminder of how much was in play when the company was still proving itself.

The take-private push of 2018

The take-private effort covered in the sources dates to August 2018. On 7 August that year, Musk announced on Twitter that he was considering taking Tesla private for $420 per share.2 Reuters described it as a $72 billion deal.2 At the time, Musk owned about a fifth of Tesla.2

Musk’s plan was not a standard leveraged buyout in which every other shareholder cashes out and new debt pays for the deal.2 Instead, he estimated that two-thirds of shareholders would choose to “roll” their stakes and stay on as investors in a private Tesla, which would sharply cut the cash needed.2 That mattered because Tesla then carried a debt pile of $11 billion and had negative cash flow, according to Reuters.2

Musk also said Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, which had taken a stake of just under 5 per cent in Tesla earlier in 2018, could help fund the cash portion of the deal, though sources close to the fund played that down.2

Why he walked away

Late on Friday, 24 August 2018, Musk said he would no longer pursue the deal.2 In a blog post, he explained what he heard from investors:2

Although the majority of shareholders I spoke to said they would remain with Tesla if we went private, the sentiment, in a nutshell, was ‘please, don’t do this’

He said some institutional shareholders had internal compliance limits on how much they could hold in a private company, and that there was no proven path for most retail investors to own shares in a private Tesla.2 He also put the mission first:2

This is a problem because we absolutely must stay focused on ramping Model 3 and becoming profitable

Musk said the process had reinforced his belief that there was more than enough funding to take Tesla private.2 Six Tesla directors said they had been told of his decision, and the board disbanded a special committee of three directors set up to review any offer.2 The episode also brought investor lawsuits and an SEC investigation into his tweet that funding was “secured”, Reuters reported.2

A Tesla Model 3 electric sedan
A Tesla Model 3. In 2018 Musk said Tesla had to stay focused on ramping Model 3 and becoming profitable.Photo: Alexander-93, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Where SoftBank’s money went instead

The other half of Musk’s post is WeWork, and the record there is well documented. By October 2019, SoftBank Group and its Vision Fund had about $11 billion invested in the shared-workspace company, according to Wccftech, and SoftBank owned one-third of it.3 That is close to the $12 billion figure in Musk’s post.13

SoftBank had valued WeWork at about $47 billion at the start of 2019.3 Before WeWork’s IPO was shelved, its valuation had reportedly fallen to somewhere between $10 billion and $20 billion.3 Wccftech tied the shelved listing to breaches of corporate governance standards and investor concern that the business model was exposed to a recession.3 Fox Business noted that co-founder Adam Neumann held 20 times the voting power of ordinary shareholders, and that WeWork had raised $12 billion in the run-up to the withdrawn IPO.4

The months that followed were rough. Multiple reports said WeWork could face bankruptcy by the end of November 2019 without new funding, and the company worked with JPMorgan Chase to try to raise at least $5 billion in new debt.3 Fox Business cited reports that it could lay off 4,000 workers.4 SoftBank prepared a financial plan to take control of WeWork, raising its stake above 50 percent, in an effort Wccftech described as Son’s attempt to salvage the money already invested.3

Analysts at Sanford C. Bernstein estimated the Vision Fund might write down as much as $5.93 billion, and SoftBank itself another $1.24 billion, on their WeWork holdings.3

Masayoshi Son, chief executive of SoftBank Group
Masayoshi Son, chief executive of SoftBank Group.Photo: Masaru Kamikura from Japan, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Son’s own shift in 2019

Son himself signalled a change of course as several SoftBank-backed companies struggled. In an interview reported by Fox Business, he said he may turn his focus from startups to “companies with clearer pathways to profitability and public offerings.”4 Fox Business listed WeWork alongside other SoftBank- and Vision Fund-linked names that were cutting staff in 2019.4

Set against that backdrop, Musk’s post reads as a reminder of the choice he says was on the table: a quarter of Tesla, in his telling, or WeWork.1

Why the post matters

For Tesla fans, the post adds a first-person detail to the take-private chapter. Musk’s 2018 explanation focused on shareholders who wanted to stay invested and the need to keep building Model 3.2 His new post names a specific investor and a specific figure, and gives his blunt view of how that investor used the money.1

It also underlines a point Musk made in 2018: he believed there was more than enough funding to take Tesla private.2 Tesla ultimately stayed a publicly listed company.2 Musk chose to keep the team focused on production and profitability rather than on a time-consuming deal.2

The limits of the evidence are clear. The account of Masa and the $12 billion comes from Musk’s post alone.1 None of the sources ENN reviewed include SoftBank’s version of events, and the post does not say when this happened.

What to watch next

  • A SoftBank reply. Whether Son or SoftBank responds to Musk’s account. No response appears in the sources so far.
  • More detail from Musk. Whether he adds a date or further context in follow-up posts.
  • The thread. ENN will follow Musk’s comments on Son and SoftBank here as new developments come.

Questions readers ask

What did Elon Musk say about Masayoshi Son?

In an 11 November post, Musk said Masa, instead of putting $12 billion into Tesla for a quarter of the company to help him take Tesla private, invested the money in WeWork. He added: "That was dumb."

When did Musk try to take Tesla private?

In August 2018 Musk said on Twitter he was considering taking Tesla private at $420 per share, a deal Reuters valued at $72 billion. He dropped the plan later that month. His new post does not give a date for the Masa episode.

How much did SoftBank put into WeWork?

Wccftech reported in October 2019 that SoftBank and its Vision Fund had about $11 billion invested in WeWork, and that SoftBank owned a third of the company.

Has SoftBank responded?

None of the sources ENN reviewed include a response from Son or SoftBank to Musk's post.

Sources

Each story is checked against the original material and independent reporting. Numbers in the text point here.

  1. 1
    PrimaryPost by @elonmusk on Masayoshi Son, Tesla and WeWork X (@elonmusk) · Nov 11, 2026
  2. 2
    CoverageTesla CEO Elon Musk drops take-private plan BusinessLine (Reuters) · Aug 25, 2018
  3. 3
    CoverageSoftBank Preparing to Stake its Claim on WeWork Wccftech · Oct 14, 2019
  4. 4