SpaceXElon's post · 15 NovHE ASKED A CRITIC HOW SPACEX CATCHES STARSHIPS

SpaceX Critic Challenged to Explain How SpaceX Catches Starships

Elon Musk takes a critic's claim that money alone builds rockets like Starship at face value, then asks him to explain how SpaceX catches giant starships from orbit.

Illustration of a launch tower's mechanical arms reaching for a descending rocket at night
Musk asked a critic to explain how SpaceX catches giant starships from orbit. Illustration: ENNIllustration
AT A GLANCE
Elon's post · 15 Nov

Musk's X post shows what he said and asked; his figures on Falcon, Blue Origin, Boeing and ULA are his own claims, not independently checked here.

When
November 15, 2026, on X
The critic's argument, per Musk
Anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon
Musk's question
How SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks
Falcon figure Musk cited
85% of all Earth payload to orbit
ULA figure Musk cited
Less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit
STORY THREAD Musk answers SpaceX criticsFirst report in this thread. Updates will appear here.

Elon Musk has a set of pointed questions for one of SpaceX’s critics. In a post on X on November 15, Musk took aim at the argument that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon, and invited the man making it to explain how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit1. It is a classic Musk move: rather than a long rebuttal, he answered with the record and asked the critic to account for it.

The challenge Musk posted

Musk opened by accepting the critic’s premise for the sake of argument1:

Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.

From there, he turned the premise into a test. If money alone were enough, Musk asked, how is SpaceX able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon1? Musk did not name the critic anywhere in the post, referring to him only as “this gentleman”1.

The questions he put to the critic

Musk’s post went well beyond one question. He laid out a series of comparisons with other players in the launch business, each framed as something the critic should be able to explain if spending were the whole story1:

  • Blue Origin: Musk said the company started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, yet is not yet able to launch reliably1.
  • Boeing and Lockheed: He said both received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft1.
  • Boeing’s capsule: Musk said it is still not operational1.
  • ULA: He said ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit1.

He ended on a note of curiosity rather than anger, writing that he is “genuinely curious about these questions”1. The figures in the post are Musk’s own; his post is the source for them, and ENN reports them as his claims.

The same day, Musk also had a kinder word for one of the companies on that list. Replying to ULA, he wrote: “Sorry to hear this. Hope you are back to flight soon.”2 ENN covered that message in its report on Musk’s note to ULA.

The SpaceX launch tower at Starbase near Boca Chica, Texas
The launch tower at SpaceX's Starbase facility in South Texas.Illustration

What catching giant rockets has looked like

The catch Musk pointed to is one of the hardest feats in the business. During SpaceX’s seventh Starship flight test in January 2025, the Super Heavy first-stage booster made a controlled descent back to the launch tower and was caught by the tower’s giant robotic arms, which ABC News described as one of the most challenging aspects of the mission3. That was the second time SpaceX had returned and caught the booster with the tower3.

In March 2025, SpaceX did it again. ABC13 Houston reported that the booster slowed from supersonic speeds before being caught by the tower’s arms, marking the third time SpaceX had returned and caught the stage that way4. Those flights also had setbacks: the upper-stage ship was lost on both the January and March tests, and the FAA required SpaceX to investigate the March mishap34. SpaceX said it would conduct a thorough investigation with the FAA and make improvements on future flight tests4.

The goal was always bigger than the booster. ABC13 reported that the March 2025 mission’s reentry experiments were meant to get SpaceX closer to bringing the upper stage back to the launch site for an eventual catch, which would make Starship completely reusable4. In October 2026, India Today reported that Musk said SpaceX would attempt to catch Starship on its 15th flight, building on its efforts to recover and reuse the Super Heavy booster with the tower’s giant mechanical arms5.

Why reuse is the heart of the argument

Musk’s challenge rests on the idea that reusable rockets are hard to build no matter the budget, and that SpaceX has spent years making them work. Falcon 9 has flown for years with a partially reusable design, while SpaceX says Starship is designed to be fully reusable34. ABC News reported that SpaceX plans for Starship to eventually include a heat shield that can be rapidly redeployed without significant refurbishing, and that the system will eventually be able to carry up to 100 people on long-duration interplanetary flights3.

Musk has been clear about why this matters to him. India Today quoted him saying, “Most people in the world don’t realise how important this technology is,” and reported his view that the only way to extend consciousness beyond Earth is through a fully reusable launch vehicle5. The outlet added that a modified Starship is planned as a lunar lander for NASA’s Artemis program5.

The ambition is huge. India Today reported that Musk expects Starship to fly once a week in the first half of 2027, rising to twice a week by the end of that year5. The outlet also noted that airline-like operations remain a formidable engineering challenge, requiring reliable reentry, precise recovery, rapid refurbishment and repeated launches5.

A SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket lifting off
A SpaceX Falcon 9, the rocket Musk says carries 85% of all Earth payload to orbit.Photo: Austin LoweryNASA/SpaceX, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

A busy day on Musk’s feed

The critic post was one of several Starship-related posts Musk shared that weekend. Earlier on November 15, he wrote that he had been going over the whole Starship heat shield and that, overall, it “looks great,” adding that “the engines look great too”6. He said Ship 42 could probably be reflown with a few weeks of refurbishment6.

Musk was also candid about the work still ahead. In the same post, he said many small fixes are needed to achieve immediate reusability like an airplane, which requires zero expected refurbishment apart from scheduled maintenance6. In a separate reply, he said Ship 42 “brings back a motherlode of data for further improvements to the heat shield”7.

He also looked ahead to the next version of the vehicle. On November 16, Musk posted that Starship V4 will be about 70 meters long, roughly a 40% length increase allowing more than 60% more propellant, with engine count raised to 9 by adding 3 more Raptor-Vacuum engines8. And in a lighter moment, he predicted that “ship, in the future, will almost always be taken to mean spaceship”9.

What to watch next

Musk framed his post as a set of open questions, so the first thing to watch is whether the unnamed critic responds1. Musk’s figures on Falcon’s share of payload and ULA’s share are his own, and readers may see them debated as the conversation continues1.

Beyond the argument itself, the bigger story is SpaceX’s push toward full reuse. Musk has said many small fixes are still needed before Starship can fly again with no expected refurbishment6, and India Today reported his target of weekly Starship flights in the first half of 20275. Each step toward those goals adds to the record Musk pointed to when he asked his critic for answers.

Questions readers ask

What did Elon Musk ask the SpaceX critic?

Musk asked the critic to explain how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin is not yet able to launch reliably.

Who is the critic?

Musk did not name him. He referred to him only as "this gentleman" and summed up his argument as anyone being able to throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.

What did Musk say about Boeing, Lockheed and ULA?

He said Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for rocket and spacecraft development, yet the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit.

Has SpaceX caught rockets with its launch tower before?

Yes. ABC News reported the tower's giant robotic arms caught the Super Heavy booster in January 2025, the second such catch, and ABC13 reported a third catch in March 2025.

What is SpaceX aiming for next with Starship?

India Today reported that Musk expects Starship to fly once a week in the first half of 2027, rising to twice a week by the end of that year, as SpaceX works toward full reusability.

Sources

Each story is checked against the original material and independent reporting. Numbers in the text point here.

  1. 1
    PrimaryMusk post challenging a SpaceX critic X (@elonmusk) · Nov 15, 2026
  2. 2
    PrimaryMusk reply to ULA X (@elonmusk) · Nov 15, 2026
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
    PrimaryMusk post on Ship 42's heat shield and engines X (@elonmusk) · Nov 15, 2026
  7. 7
    PrimaryMusk post on Ship 42 heat shield data X (@elonmusk) · Nov 15, 2026
  8. 8
    PrimaryMusk post on Starship V4 size and engines X (@elonmusk) · Nov 16, 2026
  9. 9
    PrimaryMusk post: ship will mean spaceship X (@elonmusk) · Nov 15, 2026